Thursday, 13 November 2014

YMI:
Yeh Mera India

Also Known As:
Breaking News
Year:
2008
Country:
India…
Predominant Genre:
Crime
Director:
N. Chandra…
Outstanding Performances:
None.
Premiss:
Lives of several people intertwine during an eventful day in Mumbai.
Themes:
Alienation
Compassion
Destiny
Emotional repression
Empathy
Friendship
Humanity
Identity
Loneliness
Loyalty
Narcissism
Personal change
Solipsism
Stereotyping
Similar (in Plot, Theme or Style) to:
Crash
Review Format:
DVD

Zero-Sum Game

There are rather too many coincidences in this too non-realistic melodrama but the religious hatreds exposed are spot on. Not only that but this movie actually poses solutions in terms of remembering more what is good rather than bad and letting what you remember be your guide in life. Indeed, this well-titled film makes it clear why breaking news can be so depressing to watch since it usually involves the deaths of large numbers of people.

The materialism that foments terrorism is shown to fail as an ethical and a political philosophy because any true separation between peoples is impossible because people do not live fully merely as objects. This explains the intersecting story-lines here; successfully augmented by the superb quality of the acting on display. The latter helps overcome the contrived and rather naïve aspect to the drama which is nonetheless topical and heartfelt.

Terrorism is presented as a zero-sum game of internecine conflict leading nowhere. This movie is also largely a paean to an India in a difficult transition period with its manifold past problems and the general difficulties of rapid cultural change. There is honesty about politics here absent from Western films that is more than refreshing and more than just a breath of fresh air.


Copyright © 2014 Frank TALKER. Permission granted to reproduce and distribute this posting in any format; provided mention of the author’s Weblog (Esthetics) is included: E-mail notification requested. All other rights reserved.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Contact Form:

Name

Email *

Message *

Science:



No science is immune to the infection of politics and the corruption of power.



Jacob Bronowski… (1908 - 74), British scientist, author. Encounter (London, July 1971).


Sleep of Reason:



The dream of reason produces monsters. Imagination deserted by reason creates impossible, useless thoughts. United with reason, imagination is the mother of all art and the source of all its beauty.



Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes… (1746-1828), Spanish painter. Caption to Caprichos, number 43, a series of eighty etchings completed in 1798, satirical and grotesque in form.


Humans & Aliens:



I am human and let nothing human be alien to me.



Terence… (circa 190-159 BC), Roman dramatist. Chremes, in The Self-Tormentor [Heauton Timorumenos], act 1, scene 1.


Führerprinzip:



One leader, one people, signifies one master and millions of slaves… There is no organ of conciliation or mediation interposed between the leader and the people, nothing in fact but the apparatus - in other words, the party - which is the emanation of the leader and the tool of his will to oppress. In this way the first and sole principle of this degraded form of mysticism is born, the Führerprinzip, which restores idolatry and a debased deity to the world of nihilism.