Thursday 17 September 2009

Comrades
(1986)

RATING:100%
FORMAT:DVD


An impressive achievement on a low budget, this is ultimately a human and humane drama about the human face. They loom large throughout and offer us glimpses into character - and great character acting. They determine our own emotional allegiances and those of the characters surveyed; while forming the basis for the entire plot and story. Moreover, the landscape itself is a character in its own right that supports the human figures in this deeply rural context via the expressive photography.

Unsurprisingly, the Anglican Church is collaborating with the rich to keep the poor subservient and landless; while sermonizing on each man keeping his place that appointed him of god. This is, of course, a film about boat rockers from whom the dramatic conflicts shown spring. This film is a hymn to strong leadership and communal values: A theme of which it never loses sight despite its length. It is also a hymn of praise to the expressive possibilities of cinema itself.

The narrative progression is both parallel and chronological in its poetically non linear way. This is a slow moving and beautiful experience – both in an ethical and in an aesthetic sense. The film is shot as a silent movie with emotions conveyed largely by bodily movement and facial expression. Plus, the different acting styles convey different moods in a movie part of whose brilliance lies in the extremely deft casting choices, particularly Robin SOANS as the rebel leader.

The cheerful anachronisms of the single finger, the poor characters' good teeth, breaking the fourth wall and the modern dialogue are all experimental ways of helping the director (Bill DOUGLAS) make these people real to us now. Furthermore, the movie comments on its own illusionism with the Brechtian leitmotif of an itinerant magic lantern show using the same actor (the brilliantly versatile Alex NORTON) for the characters that comment on the action - and sometimes take part in it. By appearing in various guises, NORTON enables this entire bag of cinematic tricks to cohere into a political masterpiece – all the more effective because it does not ram its various points down our throats.


Copyright © 2014 Frank TALKER. Permission granted to reproduce and distribute it in any format; provided that mention of the author’s Weblog (http://franktalker5.blogspot.com/) is included: E-mail notification requested. All other rights reserved.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Contact Form:

Name

Email *

Message *

Science:



No science is immune to the infection of politics and the corruption of power.



Jacob Bronowski… (1908 - 74), British scientist, author. Encounter (London, July 1971).


Sleep of Reason:



The dream of reason produces monsters. Imagination deserted by reason creates impossible, useless thoughts. United with reason, imagination is the mother of all art and the source of all its beauty.



Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes… (1746-1828), Spanish painter. Caption to Caprichos, number 43, a series of eighty etchings completed in 1798, satirical and grotesque in form.


Humans & Aliens:



I am human and let nothing human be alien to me.



Terence… (circa 190-159 BC), Roman dramatist. Chremes, in The Self-Tormentor [Heauton Timorumenos], act 1, scene 1.


Führerprinzip:



One leader, one people, signifies one master and millions of slaves… There is no organ of conciliation or mediation interposed between the leader and the people, nothing in fact but the apparatus - in other words, the party - which is the emanation of the leader and the tool of his will to oppress. In this way the first and sole principle of this degraded form of mysticism is born, the Führerprinzip, which restores idolatry and a debased deity to the world of nihilism.